RUSSIA AFTER THE COUP
This is a story Michael (Ross) was working on for his third book during his final days at home. It’s an early draft… he would have undoubtedly finessed it prior to publication but of course even a draft from Ross is well written. An interesting insight into Russia in the early 1990’s and packed with the acute observations readers of his books have come to enjoy.
INTRODUCTION
In the summer of 1991, whilst still working as a university lecturer, I booked an Intourist holiday in the then USSR. It was, however, a time of radical turmoil in that country; and between confirming the booking and the scheduled departure date, the old Russian empire came to an end - and a new era began.
As things turned out, the spectacular shift in 1991 from the dead weight of Communism to something like the Russia of today was virtually bloodless. Consequently, although the trip was in doubt for a week or two, it was eventually given the go-ahead; and so, along with a group of about twenty-five British tourists, I took off from Heathrow in a state of considerable excitement.
Although I’d taken a fully supportive attitude towards the West during the course of the Cold War, my eagerness to visit Russia was nevertheless apolitical. Instead, I was much more interested in pre-revolutionary culture and the arts - with a particular emphasis on the architecture of Russian religious buildings. And of course, at a simpler level, I was anxious to see precisely what that society was like after so many decades under wraps.
When I returned home, still in thrall to so many exciting events, I made a record of them almost at once. But unfortunately, after settling back into regular British life, I put the document to one side and let it stagnate until, only a few months ago and over thirty years later, I was persuaded to look again at those first heady days of political renewal. The following story is the result; and in the oddest of ways, going over old ground has been almost like embarking on a new adventure. And therefore, by sharing the freshness of my experience with present-day readers, I hope more light will be shed on the longer-term development of a society that many people still find perplexing.
Given the passage of time, I’m now unable to remember and therefore to authenticate many of the presumed hard facts I gathered during the course of the journey. Neither am I entirely clear how I acquired some of them - although the various tour guides were certainly important sources. Despite this caveat, I nevertheless feel that the original text presents the experience in a way that will genuinely excite the interest of today’s readers. I’ve therefore chosen to leave the document more or less as it was - except for the alteration of verbal tenses to reflect the thirty-year time lapse. I’ve also excluded comments and opinions no longer relevant in the face of subsequent history. And lastly, as a helpful addition at the end of the story, there’s a checklist of the various Russian terms for ‘street’ or ‘road’ - plus a number of other frequently used words.
With these provisos, I therefore believe that readers will have a good chance of sharing in the pleasure of a unique journey which was still in full swing at the very moment when the guide on board our coach announced that our destination, the city of Leningrad, had just formally resumed its pre-revolutionary title of St Petersburg. And it was there, feeling very much on the crest of a wave, in the middle of our holiday, that we all arrived not long afterwards in a state of eager anticipation.
Ross Hill - 1st September 2024
RUSSIA AFTER THE COUP
MOSCOW
Immediately after landing at Moscow’s Sheremetyevo Airport, we emerged into the half-hearted, late afternoon light and made our way, somewhat bewildered, through customs and security. Uncertain about what would happen next, we then moved on towards the exit where a modest crowd was awaiting family members or friends. In addition, of course, there were other organised groups of tourists who, like us, were eager to locate someone they’d never seen or heard of before - someone, hopefully, with a clear means of identification. In our own case, I’m glad to say we were lucky; and in just a few minutes, someone spotted a placard bearing the words 'Intourist Group from London Heathrow’. This was held aloft on a makeshift pole by a very pleasant and reassuring young woman who, as she explained later, would be accompanying us throughout the tour in order to look after our welfare, liaise with the hotels and organise the specific duties of the local guides. We soon got to know her very well indeed. Her name was Antonia - and we all felt very much at ease in her company.
* * *
Despite our growing enthusiasm on the threshold of new sights and sounds, the coach ride into the city confirmed everyone’s pre-existing stereotype. Among other things, this included the dreary, featureless blocks of state-owned flats - all of them many storeys high, grey, and in apparently poor shape. Given the context, the word ‘shape’ covers both the condition and the repetitious monotony of the architecture whose main interest, at least for me, lay in the scatter of dimly lit windows glimmering in the encroaching dusk. And as I look back, I remember trying to imagine what sort of lives were being lived behind those dark, forbidding walls - although the picture that came to mind must have owed a great deal to the naïvety of a westerner paying his first visit to a new country. At the same time, it was no surprise, that by the time the coach drew up outside our hotel, most of us were hoping for brighter prospects.
Intourist’s vast Cosmos Hotel, built among the housing estates at about nine kilometres from the city centre, provided a modicum of architectural relief which nevertheless showed little sign of the ‘brighter prospects’ I’d been anticipating. Furthermore, the first dinner, served shortly after settling into our rooms, was also a disappointment - starting with a tough and shrivelled steak topped with a solidified fried egg and accompanied by chips made by cutting small unpeeled potatoes into quarters. To be fair, however, the bedrooms were comfortable; and the TV programmes, although entirely in Russian, seemed very lively and professional.
Luckily, there was another, more positive side to the picture; and with western-style saunas and a swimming pool in the basement, the hotel was to prove among the best of the tour in terms of its facilities and shops. But the fact that the huge banqueting hall was the scene of nightly wedding receptions on a correspondingly vast scale failed to mitigate the building’s characterlessness. Guests were also obliged to show their room cards to somewhat rough-looking bouncers on returning to the hotel after a stroll; and the fact that the tarmac on the road outside was littered with untidy heaps of rubble was somewhat symptomatic of the country’s general condition. The food was set to improve, however, after a discouraging first night.
THE CITY
After breakfast on the following day, the organised City Tour presented what we all hoped would be a fresh start. Buildings acquired greater character as we approached the central areas; and there were some exciting new vistas provided by surviving churches with gilded onion domes among many other attractive features. By contrast, two extremely pale-faced Hare Krishna devotees were spotted entering the Moscow metro in their incongruous saffron outfits; and at one particular set of traffic lights, I was astonished to see that a few teenage boys had caught on to the (then popular) windscreen-wash craze imported from Western Europe.
Action-packed as throughout the tour, we then drove round the base of the demolished Dzerzhinsky statue which - as witnessed on my home TV only ten days previously - still sported the fresh graffiti and the Russian flag. We also drove past the White House - scene of the most crucial demonstrations connected with the recent fall of the Soviet Union; and there were still flowers on the pavement where, unfortunately, a young protester had been killed. The coach then drove on to Red Square where we faced the first full onslaught of souvenir sellers.
Red Square
In 1991, throughout the lives of adults old enough to remember, the picture of Red Square had been the most memorable symbol of Soviet power with its annual parades of armoury overseen by the grim-faced rulers of the so-called Evil Empire. And consequently, for a group of British tourists like us, it was not to be compared with a leisurely excursion to Trafalgar Square or Buckingham Palace. This impression was based on more than mere association: the redbrick walls of the Kremlin, augmented by a line of conifers, still reflected the lingering might of an imperial fortress that seemingly dwarfed the shapely ziggurat of Lenin’s tomb. And by contrast, of course, there was the Italianate but half-empty allure of the Gum Department Store.
As once-in-a-lifetime visitors, we also made a point of witnessing the changing of the guard at Lenin’s mausoleum since it was rumoured it would soon be discontinued. The slow-motion goose-step was weirdly mechanical, and the clean-shaven militia was conspicuously youthful. Furthermore, their timing was so exact that they completed an amazingly long march from the Kremlin gates at the precise moment when the clock struck the hour.
Last but not least, St. Basil’s Cathedral in Red Square was far from being the toylike structure it always appears to be on television. Instead, when viewed against the fast-moving clouds of a northern sky, it looked massive and imposing, and the technicolour domes, soaring over the redbrick bastions beneath them, were agreeably weathered. There is no doubt it was commissioned by Ivan the Terrible; but although historians differ as to whether there were two architects or possibly just one, our guide favoured the former option and maintained that, in both cases, their genius was rewarded by having their eyes gouged out - thereby ensuring they could never again improve on what, in the event, was to be their final masterpiece! And in spite of its questionable authenticity, it was an unusually sobering story that pursued us like a shadow as we moved on.
The Kremlin
A visit to the Kremlin was naturally a must. And to foreigners, once inside this citadel of power, the images that presented themselves were surprising in relation to the known record of the Soviet Union. The ochre stucco of the Tsar’s residence and the gilded cathedral domes were sights much at variance with the former dogmas of the communists. Even the crosses, flashing in the brilliant sunlight, remained as silent reminders of a world view expressly prohibited from within the same walls until what were very recent times.
Less controversial but equally interesting, the historical collections in the Kremlin’s Armoury Museum were spectacular. The fabrics, the ecclesiastical vestments, court dress, jewellery, icons and royal coaches were well displayed; and one could pause and gaze in wonderment with one’s eyes just a few centimetres from the fur-lined crown of Ivan the Terrible.
I was particularly taken with the royal sledge of Catherine the Great which really amounted to a coach on skis. The design, however, was less Cinderella-like and more intensely Russian than the other vehicles in the collection; and one could picture the royal passengers, heavily wrapped in layers of protective clothing, as they sped, drawn by twelve horses, through the hostile winter landscape between St Petersburg and Moscow. It’s also worth mentioning that, according to our guide, the same journey by train in 1991 still took about eight hours.
​
Kolomenskoye Country Estate
Our short stay in Moscow provided limited opportunities for individual exploration. On the other hand, there was still time enough for several events organised by Intourist. The first of these was a visit to the Kolomenskoye Country Estate which had been turned into an open-air museum of traditional Russian life. It included Peter the Great’s original log cabin (used as a hunting lodge) which overlooked the city and the Moskva River and was fully furnished. Set in a green, deciduous forest pierced by the sharp flicker of late-summer sun, it provided a telling insight into antique Russian architecture - much of it wooden. And speaking personally, I was particularly struck by finding such an unfamiliar sort of building among tree species that would have been just as much at home in London’s Hyde Park.
There was also a recently reopened church whose blue cupolas spangled with gold stars had survived the years of ideological repression. As a church, of course, it predated the latterday creation of an open-air museum. And on top of adding colour and charm to the natural environment, it had also resumed its primary function as a place of worship.
* * *
At the approaches to Kolomenskoye (much like tourist venues everywhere else in Russia), there was ample opportunity to make contact with the vendors of military watches and 'Gorby' dolls. These budding entrepreneurs were mostly young men; and I thought it rather amusing that they’d all latched on to the English diminutive of the then famous name of Mikhail Gorbachev who had contributed so much to the political changes of the day. It was here too that I experienced the first face-to-face encounter with wrinkled babushkas making the sign of the cross and begging for alms: it was a sight with an appeal to one’s better self that couldn’t be disregarded.
Finally, it has to be emphasised that, during our extensive travels, none of us ever had to contend with beggars that targeted us as tourists in the persistent or aggressive manner familiar in many other parts of the world. It was a striking cultural difference - particularly bearing in mind that, even in contemporary London, one can be verbally abused by a vagrant whose requests for money have been ignored.
Park of Economic and Scientific Achievement
Opposite Intourist’s Cosmos Hotel on Mira Prospekt and close to the metro station, there was one particular venue which - although missing from the official literature - was well worth investigating. This was the variously named Park of Economic and Scientific Achievement which, for visiting westerners like me, was far more interesting in terms of people-spotting than it was for those whose chief concern was scientific. For example, the countless local Muscovites gathered there were clearly enjoying a leisurely stroll and seemed content to devote their time to fingering the cheap-and-cheerful goods in the many boutiques - or tackling the ice creams which, as we soon discovered, were popular throughout the country. I also discovered a large crowd near an activity area where the ‘big wheel’, loaded with fun-lovers, was rotating at a frightening speed. And for me, this provided a familiar and diverting spectacle which confirmed that ordinary Russians are liable to scream in exactly the same way as Brits at a seaside fair when mercilessly whirled about in the equivalent of an oversize spinning-top.
True to its description as a park, however, there was also plenty of green space punctuated at intervals by what looked like ornate marble palaces. In reality, these were museums variously devoted to the ‘scientific achievement’ aspect of an enterprise where leisure activity had to some degree supplanted the intended emphasis on education. With the result that, as an independent observer, my interest remained firmly focussed on the citizens of a very different country who were out and about enjoying themselves.
But I soon came face to face with another surprise of a rather different sort; and as I prepared to return to the hotel, I was confounded by a singular incongruity at the exit. This took the form of a brass band - nothing unusual about that, you might say - but it was a brass band playing ‘The Beer Barrel Polka’ whose first line ‘Roll out the Barrel’ I’d known since I was a boy. Neither had I forgotten the words of the second line ‘We’ll have a barrel of fun’. And it made me chuckle. After all, given what I’d observed in the Park of Economic and Scientific Achievement, it more or less hit the nail on the head!
The Metro
The Moscow underground has an international reputation for its outstanding architectural and decorative features; and one of the organised trips - which I didn’t join - was devoted to a tour of some of the most highly thought-of stations. The participants were full of praise; and favourable reports were also received from other members of our group who subsequently explored the system on their own. For myself, however, I have to admit that I felt unable to face the risk of getting hopelessly lost so early in the holiday; and two later reports reconciled me to that decision: firstly, a middle-aged man I’d got to know on the flight from Heathrow was surrounded by a band of teenage ruffians whom he managed to shake off in one of the tunnels; and secondly, a Japanese girl (also a member of our group) was jostled and relieved of her handbag by a similar gang. I don’t think anyone ever explained to me how to recognise a Russian hoodlum; but I do remember having read an article in a British newspaper which claimed that ‘bully boys from the provinces’ were a recurrent threat in various parts of the Russian capital.
ENTERTAINMENT
The stay in Moscow, like all the cities covered during our travels, was necessarily brief. All the same, whilst we were there, Intourist made every effort to provide us with variety. It’s impossible, of course, to know how selective the choice of venues actually was; but if the entertainments to which we were introduced were in any way representative, then the following two examples must surely cast doubt on the negative coverage we’d been used to hearing back home.
The Moscow State Circus
I was greatly impressed (and entertained) by the Moscow State Circus. It possessed class and was hugely amusing. The principal clown was especially polished and had depth; the animals showed no signs of disgruntlement - and chimps mounted on dogs dressed as horses (plus the bears in red gym shorts) rivalled the excellent acrobats and scantily dressed prima donnas. Despite the language barrier, I also suspected that a high proportion of the wit was as much intelligent parody as it was pure slapstick. It was also a pleasure to listen to the sound of fluent Russian; and not being able to understand it helped to appreciate the melody rather than the meaning.
The Puppet Theatre
​
I was equally delighted with the Puppet Theatre - the puppets being just under half life-size - whilst the dimensions of the auditorium were similarly reduced in scale to match them. Furthermore, in the foyer, there was a first-class collection of marionettes from across the globe - so it was a good thing we arrived early enough to have a close look before the show began - a circumstance that spared the audience, already in place, from the intrusive noise of late-comers.
As to the performance, I found it both skilful and suitably lighthearted: it was presented as a variety show complete with a puppet acting as the compère; and even for foreigners, there was sufficient music, dancing and other high jinks to compensate for the fact that none of us could understand the dialogue. On top of this, although as an experience it was very different from the Moscow State Circus, we all enjoyed it just as much.
MUNICIPAL HOUSING ESTATES
To be true to this capital city, it’s important to revisit the northern suburb in which I was staying among mile after mile of run-down flats bereft of all character. The only redeeming feature was the amount of woodland scrub that divided them up, the unmown patches of grass, and what (for me) were the familiar-looking weeds flourishing between the paving stones. Drab social housing estates, of course, are not unique to Russia; but in Moscow their scale at the time of our visit was (or appeared to be) vast. They possessed neither centre nor focus; and their endless duplication throughout the country became more evident as our travels continued.
In view of the foregoing rather negative summary, readers may perhaps understand the reason why, as I explored the immediate environs of the hotel, I included a quiet cemetery embedded in woods so thick that they entirely concealed the municipal dwellings that enclosed them. A recently reopened church was still encased in scaffolding; and despite the lack of a common language, two elderly men who touched me for a few roubles managed to convey their immense satisfaction with the fall of the old system of government.
​
DEPARTURE FOR THE UKRAINE
Departure for the Ukrainian capital, Kiev, after only a few all-too-short days, was from Moscow’s second airport (Domodedovo) which, once entered, reminded me of a somewhat run-down provincial bus station in the UK. The boutiques numbered about three - plus a bar - and that was all there was to it, other than the waiting room with its worn-out seating and a television showing a western-style thriller set in the Russian arctic. Before boarding the flight, I considered it wise to take a fairly obvious precaution; and at first, the public convenience appeared to pass the litmus test when viewed from the outside. Once I’d gained access, however, it sank below par - for it was dirty and untidy with cracked tiles and discoloured wash basins. Furthermore, there was a choice of only two cubicles: one of the type familiar in the West (in use at the time) and the other in the Asian style which was particularly filthy. I decided to wait until I’d boarded the aircraft where, I assured myself, things could hardly be any worse!
Aeroflot Services
The two-hour flight to Kiev combined a fairytale panorama of billowing cumulus with intriguing snatches of the vast landscape which, until recently, had been largely out of bounds to foreigners. I was full of enthusiasm; and as the in-flight trolley approached, I prepared myself for a nice glass of wine - or better still, a decent tot of vodka - perhaps the lemon-flavoured variety I’d previously sampled in London. But this was not to be; and sadly, the only refreshment on offer was a mineral water of unpleasant flavour which had lost most of its fizz before reaching the lips of the many disappointed passengers. Nevertheless, with the sights and sounds of a new city ahead of us, most of us took things in our stride.
KIEV
The airport at Kiev looked more encouraging than its somewhat tawdry Moscow counterpart; and the boutiques selling souvenirs were more numerous. There was also a liquor shop which enabled me to acquire some vodka at a reasonably competitive price; and best of all: the sun was shining brightly.
Intourist’s rather unimaginatively named ‘Intourist Hotel’ reinforced the weather’s favourable overtures and was among the most comfortable we were to encounter throughout the entire trip. The three shops, the bar, the bedrooms and the food all passed muster. However, there was one calamitous and somewhat ironical exception to all this, since it was here that the famously eponymous ‘Chicken Kiev’ gave three of us (including myself) a nasty dose of food poisoning that clouded the horizon throughout the night and the early hours of the next morning. Other than that, the chefs did fairly well!
THE CITY
The introductory City Tour rapidly revealed a capital whose ambience was more consistently cheerful than that of Moscow. With commanding views of the Dnieper River, it had a holiday atmosphere much enhanced by the ample woodland areas intermixed with public parks that sloped lazily downwards from the urban limits to the water’s edge. Even here, however, there was no shortage of political monuments; and despite the destruction inflicted during World War II, there were many ancient survivals, including the golden domes of the churches that provided continuity with the Ukraine’s eventful past. Furthermore, the huge islands in the Dnieper had long sandy beaches which were used for sunbathing, swimming and fishing. Consequently, none of my fellow travellers had any complaints about Kiev - although the cockroach problem made its first (but not last) appearance in just a couple of hotel bedrooms.
Kiev-Perchersk Lavra
On the second morning, a voyage along the Dnieper revealed the splendour of the Kiev-Perchersk Lavra rising in white and gold magnificence from a vast acreage of riverside forest. Until the advent of Perestroika, it had been preserved as one of thousands of expropriated religious buildings euphemistically described as being of ‘historico-cultural’ interest. In 1988, however, to commemorate the millennium of the Russian Orthodox Church, it had become one of the four monasteries allowed to reopen in what, at the time, was still the Soviet Union.
After clambering ashore, and as the result of our guide’s negotiations, we were allowed to visit the catacombs where the monks had held out for long periods during the Tartar invasion. Used later on for burials, we were shown the glass-covered coffins of those whose names were still revered - each occupying a recess with its own burning lamp and an icon.
Given the pitch darkness and the lack of electricity, everyone was obliged to carry a candle. Nevertheless, notwithstanding this encumbrance, I found the tunnels silent but spotless, calm and timeless rather than eerie or evil-smelling. All the same, we had to keep close to the person ahead of us, because once he or she disappeared around the next bend, being reliant on the flame of a single candle was, to say the least of it, unnerving.
Whilst the private areas of the monastery were understandably closed to tourists, we did encounter some of the monks; and I was much struck by the youth of some of them. Out of the few members of the community we saw, all appeared under fifty, most in their mid thirties and two or three must have been in their late teens or early twenties. The solid commitment visible in their faces - together with their very existence - was something which continued to astonish all of us, bearing in mind the virtual extinction of the Church during what, in 1991, was still the not-too-distant past.
Except for our earlier trip to the Kremlin, the monastery’s principal church gave me my first sight of the level of magnificence typical of Orthodox buildings. The murals, painted in the early twentieth century, were in a manner reminiscent of Frank Brangwyn; but the clash of style with that of the icons was mysteriously resolved by an identity of spirit. In addition, the monks’ refectory was likewise painted from floor to ceiling with yet more murals which would have justified a much longer visit than there was time for.
​
* * *
After the other members of the group, along with the guide, had departed, I remained behind in order to investigate the architecture and experience the quietness at greater leisure. Whilst doing so, half-hidden behind some ramshackle building works, I discovered a chapel that hadn’t been included in the tour - and it was there that I first encountered the characteristically Russian nature of religious devotion later to be experienced in many other areas. It was true that in this specific case, in the middle of a working weekday, most of the worshippers were babushkas; but the openness and public display of their piety: the prayers spoken out loud as they venerated the icons, the impromptu hymns and the custom of kneeling and touching their foreheads on the stone flagging were customs by no means confined to the Kiev-Perchersk Lavra. And for a while, during the walk back to the hotel, I remained under the spell of what I’d seen.
​
During the short time we spent in Kiev, the leaders of the Ukraine had been assembled in full session to debate the moves consequent upon the complete political transformation which had occurred so recently. And whilst this was still in full swing, immediately after leaving the monastery, I was lucky enough to stumble on a large crowd in front of the building where the deliberations were taking place.
* * *
During my brief encounter with what was an entirely orderly event, there was no mistaking the popular fervour implied by the hundreds of placards and national flags confronting the military cordon. Moreover, as I discovered later, the proceedings inside were being simultaneously televised - rather more of a novelty for the local population than for tourists already accustomed to their own home-grown brand of ‘Glasnost’.
In the midst of all the excitement, however, there was one thing in particular that puzzled me more than anything else: namely, the fact that many demonstrators were dressed (as our guide later explained to me) in the uniform of the World War Il partisans. Unfortunately, he was unable to name the source of supply; but he added that the post-war communists had banned the movement due to its separatist sympathies.
ULITSA KRESHCHATIK
Kiev’s main thoroughfare, Ulitsa Kreshchatik was noteworthy for its considerable width combined with the congenial nature of its architecture; and despite a few Stalinist leftovers, persistent undertones of an earlier period were still present. It was therefore interesting to hear that much of it had been rebuilt after World War II following the damage inflicted by the Nazis. With the consequent result that, despite the vagaries of time and the massive proportions of the majority of structures, there were still encouraging signs of a lazier Mediterranean atmosphere.
Considering the meagre supply of goods wherever we went, the number of large shops and department stores in Ulitsa Kreshchatik was bewildering. Many of the latter were constructed with lavish appointments: huge marble lobbies and grand staircases - all no doubt intended to mark the achievements of socialism which, in the event, had completely failed to materialise. The queues, as we’d all seen back home on the TV, were ubiquitous and perpetual - every man and woman assiduously scanning the counters for anything new or, more to the point, something they actually wanted.
Understandably, the eyes of those among us who were interested in these matters found much to attract their attention. All business in the stores was conducted in semi-darkness to save the faltering electricity supply; but even if all the lights had been turned full on, they would have revealed nothing new, given that every floor was like a half-hearted closing-down sale in terms of useless commodities and general dreariness.
It was a very sad sight, of course - here and everywhere else - to see so many people rummaging for goods which in many cases they couldn’t have obtained without coupons even if they’d had enough cash to snap them up. The central issue, however, was that genuinely worthwhile merchandise simply wasn’t available. And consequently, my impression was this: that people throughout the country were seeking not only subsistence but also access to the dream world floating in on the airwaves from the West. Hence, both in Kiev and St Petersburg, I was struck by the long queues outside stores owned by Lancôme, the French cosmetic company - and by the fact that (in St Petersburg) there was a doorman busily regulating the number of would-be shoppers trying to gain entry.
* * *
Another peculiarity that astonished every member of our group was that almost all shop assistants in these grandiose retail outlets added up their customers’ bills on an abacus - something that left me in no doubt that I’d be accused of exaggerating if, when the trip was over, I told friends at home that the only modern calculator I’d seen in Russia was the one in my own pocket. A further distinctive feature of large stores and smaller shops was the approach to window dressing. Shop windows were not lacking in number, but they rarely included any actual goods. Instead, they usually paraded some rather tired three-dimensional graphics which, instead of summarising the nature of a shop’s business, made it clear there was very little, if anything, left to buy.
POLITICAL MONUMENTS
The political monuments in Kiev (as elsewhere) were too numerous and too uniform in style to make them worth listing. Unlike most of my compatriots, however, I thought that (as art) many of them deserved consideration: they were robust and assertive and, representionally speaking, very convincing. Consequently, the worst that could be said about them, here and throughout the regions we visited, was that the carbon-copy socialist realism might have been the work of a single (and closely supervised) craftsperson.
It was also the case that most of the sculptures I came across were still on display and wholly undamaged. Exceptionally, however, an enormous statue of Lenin in the city’s main square was boarded up in the wake of the recent coup; and the temporary structure surrounding it was covered with graffiti. In addition to this, there were two suitably conspicuous warnings, both printed in imposing black Cyrillics which, as translated by our guide, conveyed the following information: firstly, the edifice was about to be demolished; and secondly, the purpose of the protective boarding was to ensure public safety rather than preserve the memory of a former hero whose name had recently been blacklisted by the government.
* * *
Many monuments had wider concerns than the big names of the former USSR and took on board the Nazi occupation and its ultimate end at the hands of the defending forces. One of these was most memorable for the fact that it was overarched by a steel structure representing a rainbow that towered fifty metres or so into the air. Another extravaganza, of similarly vast height, consisted of a female figure symbolising the motherland. This was so huge that its base contained a war museum. According to the guide, however, its presence was resented by the population on the grounds that they hadn’t been consulted about the cost - an objection underpinned by the fact that it competed with the golden domes of the nearby Perchersk Monastery and spoiled what was once a much admired view. On the bright side, however, on the last day of our whistle-stop trip to Kiev - it was a view, amongst others, that I continued to remember with affection.
MOVING ON
Early on the final morning, we all set out by coach from the hotel to the airport on the next stage of our tour - this time to the Moldovan capital, Kishinyev, which some of us had to admit we’d never previously heard of. And it was certainly true that, for me as well, prior to booking the tour in the first place, Kishinyev could have been more or less anywhere. In the event, however, our ignorance boosted rather than blunted the thrill of the unknown we were about to encounter - or at least thought we were until the reality came into conflict with supposition.
* * *
The Aeroflot flight was surprisingly brief - lasting very little more than an hour, and allowing us just enough time to confront a second plastic cupful of the same unpleasant, medicinal-tasting water which (not so long ago) we’d already been introduced to.
This time, however, we were even more disconcerted to find that the aircraft itself, in a worn-out, old-fashioned sort of way, was propeller-driven - a fact that bore heavily down on me as I gazed through the window at the spinning blades within a metre of my seat. On top of this, some difficulty had arisen earlier on about closing the door properly - whilst at the same time it appeared that the wearing of seat belts had acquired a somewhat voluntary character. And last but not least, a mild anxiety based on these observations was not much alleviated by the state of the carpet.
When push came to shove, however, I managed to get used to it all. And even spotting the fact that an object was dangling on a piece of string attached to a safety pin under the propeller shaft seemed so much a matter of course that I can no longer remember exactly what it was!
​
KISHINYEV
Moldova - of which Kishinyev (Chișinău) is the capital - had reacted swiftly in the wake of the recent coup, and had joined the Ukraine and others in seeking to secede from the former USSR. Consequently, whilst still aboard the aircraft, our guide Antonia explained to us some of the difficulties that this move and its aftermath was likely to imply for the newly independent republic. The first bridge to cross, however, was a word or two about the language.
The Moldovan language, like its sister tongue across the nearby Romanian border, differed from Russian in being rooted in the Latin bequeathed by the Roman legions. Two years previously, growing national feeling had secured the official abandonment of the Cyrillic alphabet in favour of its more natural western counterpart; and for visitors unfamiliar with the region (and with Cyrillics), the improved legibility of public signs was predicted to reveal how different from Russian the indigenous language was.
In terms of politics, it was also pointed out that the most serious hurdle for Moldova as a unified state was its mufti-ethnic composition which was causing a mixed response to proposals from the country’s leader that one way forward was to align more closely with Romania than with Russia. This was a source of unease among the Russian and Ukrainian minorities. There were other minorities, too, such as a community of Turkish Christians; and to make matters even more complex, the twin towns of Bendery and Tiraspol were entirely opposed to change and were hoping to form a separate socialist republic faithful to the old principles - which would mean an entirely separate statelet within the borders of the newly independent Moldova.
We were later to have a taste of the above uncertainties whilst moving on from Kishinyev to Odessa in a coach that was briefly stopped by the Bendery militia. Further jitters were demonstrated in the centre of Bendery where one of our company was asked by a soldier why he was photographing Lenin’s statue. Luckily, our guide stepped in, and the word 'tourist' combined with the English connection, proved a sufficient explanation and we were waved on. I might as well add, somewhat ahead of time perhaps, that Bendery on a Sunday morning looked like a pile of deserted concrete slabs with grass growing out of them; and the hotel we visited solely in order to use the toilet sported a self-service dining room which would have doubled up very credibly as a former works canteen that had long since passed its sell-by date.
THE HOTEL
By the time we reached Kishinyev, most of us were far better informed about conditions in Moldova than we were before hearing our guide’s analysis as summarised above. And speaking for myself, despite being a mere sightseer like the rest of the group, I felt an odd sense of involvement in the particularities of our latest destination and looked forward to finding out more.
Nevertheless, the mood of keen anticipation didn’t last long. In fact, it petered out shortly after reaching our hotel where the first thing that put everyone off was the news that there was no hot water! It also turned out that the cold supply in the bathrooms looked unpleasantly similar to weak tea minus the milk. To soften the blow, however, the manager hurriedly explained that these defects bore no comparison with the inconvenience of the local people earlier in the year when the city’s water supply had been subject to interruption for two entire months.
Neither was this the end of the bad news; and sad to say, although the building itself, given its fourteen storeys, looked imposing in scale, it was nevertheless obvious that its grandiose proportions had not been matched by the facilities in the entrance lobby which presented a dreary appearance with a single gift shop stocked with a few books, some newspapers, and a small selection of postcards. There was very little else. It was early days, of course; but unfortunately, it was only the beginning of the troubles that lay ahead of us.
From this point onwards, my fellow travellers’ patience began to run out in relation to hotels in general and the food in particular - and not without cause in this (the latest) instance. It was noticeable, however, that my British compatriots complained the loudest whilst other members of the group, including two South Africans, one Japanese and an Australian, felt that our hosts tried very hard under intolerable conditions to meet a minimum standard. The worst shortcoming was the fact that our meals were usually served stone cold. In my own case, for example, unseasoned egg soufflés at room temperature fell far short of even basic expectations. On the other hand, and by complete contrast, the dining room was spacious and quite well maintained - in addition to which, under-the-counter brandy was obtainable from the waiters for the equivalent of about a pound sterling per bottle.
Bedrooms
By this time, I was on friendly terms with most of my fellow tourists from whom I learned, when discussing my own bedroom, that I was luckier than most of them. Front-facing and on the ninth floor, I had an interesting view from our city centre location out across the southern suburbs. And just across the road opposite the hotel, a cluster of blue onion domes added extra colour to the urban panorama.
Dull as the room was in itself, at least there were no cockroaches - a constant nuisance that was beginning to spoil the trip for several of us. All the same, despite my advantage when it came to cockroaches, I couldn’t help noticing that the windows had been draught-proofed with old-fashioned strips of sticky paper. This implied that a cleaning agent that didn’t wash them off had never been found - which also suggested that they’d seldom if ever been cleaned.
Although my room, treated as an independent spatial unit, was just about acceptable, it was overshadowed by the worst en suite bathroom I’ve ever come across - with one possible exception in the Far East. Apart from being minute in size and as dark as a nuclear winter, it was equipped with an improvised clothes line made of string. This was supplemented by a towel rail placed so high up that it was barely within reach. To exacerbate the situation even further, the blue tiles were either cracked or missing - and there was a gaping hole under the bath full of builder’s rubble. Add to this the jumble of exposed plumbing, the yellow loo seat that swivelled when in use, plus an ill-fitting cistern cap - and the picture is complete... apart from the detached cladding in one wall that revealed the rusty waste pipes from the lavatories on the floor above!
Entertainment
Given all its defects, perhaps as a means of making up for them, the hotel management lost no time in smoothing ruffled feathers by providing a modicum of entertainment. Since we’d only just arrived, I took advantage of this - although more out of curiosity than anything else. And so, at a cost of five roubles (ten pence), I attended an after-dinner concert in the dining hall given by a Romany band of uncertain provenance.
I use the word ‘uncertain’ because there was a lack of authenticity about virtually everything - or so I felt. Traditional instruments, what there was of them, were electric; and the volume of sound was ear-splitting. The men were noteworthy for their overbearing stature and their deafening voices. Above all, there was very little of the genuine middle eastern flavour I’d been expecting. On the other hand, everyone seemed to enjoy it; and later on, many couples took to the floor as soon as a more familiar, western-style dance band put in an appearance.
The Romanians
The only other memorable and by far the worst aspect of our stay at this less than comfortable hotel was that it coincided with a forty-eight hour stopover by a group of Romanian nationals whose determination to have a good time made a mockery of everyone else’s entitlement to a night’s sleep.
On top of this, it was more or less clear from the start that their main objective was the shops - notwithstanding the accompanying emphasis on fun and games; and yet, given what I soon discovered about local conditions, I cannot imagine what they expected to find in Kishinyev that they couldn’t find at home. It was possible, of course, that anything was better than the legacy of Nicolae Ceasescu, the former Romanian president and dictator, who was executed just a few years previously. And perhaps there was still a sense of freedom in the air that made them so boisterous. Unfortunately, however, I had more than enough time to think these matters over: and what still strikes me most forcibly is how appallingly noisy they were as they kept me awake until three o’clock in the morning while they traipsed around the corridors, knocking on each others’ doors, holding raucous discussions, and (in the case of the men) chasing the women from one room to another.
* * *
After breakfast on the morning following the Romanians’ second and final overnight romp, there was a great deal of much more down-to-earth activity. And as I watched, I found it impossible to imagine what it was they were carting away with them, overloaded as they all were with brown paper parcels. The value attached to whatever they’d bought was obvious - to the point that every item was wrapped with extreme care. Even the suitcases and travel bags were covered in the same brown paper as the goods. In fact, the enthusiasm and urgency in the air was almost palpable: it was as if they (with everything they’d ever dreamt of owning) were making a mad dash to the Romanian border, although there was no apparent reason for the hurry.
Naturally enough, it was with relief as well as interest that I observed them preparing to depart. Moreover, to my particular way of looking at things, there was also a comic side to it - and I had to laugh. To begin with, the worn-out coach had trouble getting started. Weighed down with the burden of people and goods, it had to be pushed and shoved from the back by a group of heavily built men whilst the driver struggled with the engine. And as I watched it crawl and lurch into the main thoroughfare with a great deal of spluttering, it was hard to imagine how a wreck like that could ever make it back to Bucharest. After all, I thought, getting much further than it already had was likely to be a very tall order.
CITY TOUR
Notwithstanding the various shortcomings such as cockroaches, lukewarm showers and leaking washbasins, we were all looking forward to the customary City Tour even before the coach arrived to pick us up. Once on board, however, there was a general feeling that the local guide’s commitment was somewhat tentative - which made it difficult to tell whether the problem was boredom or embarrassment. On the other hand, I felt very sorry for the poor woman who must have known in advance what the reaction of westerners would be like to starting off the tour with a visit to the vast municipal estates that encircled the rather more congenial central districts. Learning how the other half lives, of course, is a worthy endeavour... but hardly the stuff of holidays.
Unfortunately, there were some among us who openly complained about having to explore residential and industrial suburbs that presented no discernible points of interest. Speaking personally, however, I don’t regret having had the opportunity to take a look. Naturally, there was no way of knowing whether the itinerary was originally conceived out of civic pride or a quest for sympathy; but the experience was at least informative - although, even for me, it would have worn thin if it had lasted much longer than it did. And so, since no one could deny that this part of the excursion was disappointing, we were all glad to move on - hopefully to better prospects elsewhere.
* * *
The atmosphere brightened as soon as the coach reached what was obviously the city centre - a centre, nevertheless, that taken on its own, didn’t exactly justify a prolonged journey from London Heathrow to a little known microcosm in south-eastern Europe. Having said that, however, the main thoroughfare was architecturally passable - as were the visible sections of the many well proportioned roads crossing it at right angles.
Until the recent coup, this arterial boulevard had been somewhat predictably known as Prospekt Lenina. By the time of our visit, however, most politically sensitive street signs (Prospekt Lenina included) had been removed; but unfortunately, our somewhat detached local guide was unable to remember what the new name actually was. Nevertheless, whatever they were called, the streets looked busy in an unexceptional sort of way; and virtual normality was evident from the number of ice cream eaters and Kvas drinkers. At the same time, compared with our experience of Moscow and Kiev, there was one obvious environmental difference: namely, the fact that the ground-level atmosphere was dimmer and the temperature cooler due to the shade of the many trees with branches overhanging the pavements.
Halfway along the (for now) nameless Prospekt Lenina, starting from the southern end where the Intourist Hotel stood on the corner of Ulitsa Izmaylovskaya, there was a triumphal arch dating from 1840 standing in an extensive square with fountains that appeared to be out of order. On the opposite side of the square, a paved piazza occupied the space in front of a church where we alighted from the coach; and although the outside walls were characterised by crumbling stucco and the inside by a tangle of scaffolding, we found that the building was already provided with a makeshift iconostasis as well as a priest who was marrying an elderly couple in the company of just two wedding guests of similar age.
In contrast with this quietly intimate scene, opposite the triumphal arch on the far side of the main road, the new republic’s administrative centre was pointed out to us - as was Moldova’s national flag flying proudly from the rooftop. And by way of hammering the political point home, our attention was also drawn to the well stocked street-level flower beds which, until a week earlier, had surrounded yet another (lately demolished) statue of Lenin.
Lenin Komsomol Park
Having driven to the next scheduled stop on our tour, we all alighted from the coach and were immediately led by our guide through a heavily wooded area and then, with growing curiosity, further on until we reached a vast open space that included a boating lake of similarly ample proportions. We had arrived, it seemed, at the Lenin Komsomol Park whose revised name, assuming moves were in hand to change it, was still an unknown quantity.
During our fairly brisk walk in these pleasant open-air surroundings, what was most striking, in view of long-term and recent history, was the fact that - while yet another statue of Lenin had just been pulled down and left to its own devices - bunches of flowers had been simultaneously scattered around the surviving statues of pre-revolutionary heroes, rulers and literary figures - a phenomenon that surprised us as relatively ill-informed western visitors.
It was therefore an oddly confusing picture. And as the walkabout continued, I couldn’t help thinking that public tributes to members of the former ruling class would have been unimaginable even a few years previously. But what seemed even more intriguing was the fact that, despite almost a century of ideological conditioning, the old religions - secular, sacred and cultural - had somehow managed to live on beneath the surface. They were also proving longer lasting; and reinforced by the scene we’d just witnessed in the church, it was an impression that lingered stubbornly at the back of my mind as we boarded the coach and drove back to the hotel.
GOING IT ALONE
Kishinyev was no exception to the general rule that street markets are often among the most interesting features of city life. There’s the exhilarating conflict between order and disorder - plus a variety of telltale odours (some pleasantly evocative, some of them not). The hunt for bargains, of course, is always at the forefront; and there’s the familiar mishmash of ordinary conversation competing with the stertorous voices of the salesmen - on top of which, there’s nearly always the colourful fruit-and-veg stalls - not to mention the occasional old man or woman selling a bunch of roses grown in the back garden behind a kitchen that has hardly altered since it was built at a time now long forgotten.
In Kishinyev, along with the deeper resonance of the churches, the scene described above demonstrated an authentic spirit of place and hinted at those underlying features which, but for the dead weight of recent political history, might have imbued the whole city with the sort of individuality to be found in Provence, for example, or among the lakes of Cumbria. It was an environment which, for me, created a far more stimulating response than the main thoroughfares - thoroughfares that were not in themselves disagreeable but just too uniform and monolithic. And, to be absolutely blunt, most of them lacked anything that could be called distinctive.
* * *
Focussing now on the particularities, it’s worth mentioning that I discovered Kishinyev’s open-air market more or less by chance. It was only a stone’s throw away from Prospekt Lenina - the local equivalent of London’s Oxford Street - and I was immediately struck by the fact that it was rather like stumbling on a ramshackle concentration of stalls among the plane trees of Berkeley Square.
The merchandise I observed on sale was varied, including household goods, clothes and, by contrast, a youngish man selling audio cassettes. Dim cafés and a few run-down dives with slot machines popped up here and there; but, as always, the fruit-and-veg stalls won the day for me. It was also very refreshing to see a woman walking away after acquiring a red and green cluster of chillis still attached to the stem. And the flowers, too, provided a vital spark that brought the place to life. Sold mainly by baboushkas standing alongside their personal buckets of carnations, asters or gladioli, they were of a visibly high quality and were selling well. Other products that stood out were the varieties of nuts, the dried fruits, and the herb teas displayed in clear polythene bags so that customers could see for themselves exactly what they were getting.
By and large, it was obvious that most of the fresh foods on sale were from private gardens; but sadly, among the many examples, I couldn’t help noticing the single handful of carrots in the hands of an old woman standing by the kerb just outside the market area. Nor could I help wondering whether this pitiful end-product of careful nurture had been grown in a makeshift window box in the hopes of a few, much needed kopeks.
An Urban Village
It’s a pleasure to finish on a positive note - indeed, a more than positive note - about a city which, apart from the few aspects already described, wasn’t overwhelmingly interesting. Nevertheless, bright spots like the above-mentioned street market created a very favourable impression.
It was the day before we left Kishinyev when I encountered yet another, unexpectedly pleasant surprise - a surprise that would have been in marked contrast to the identity of just about any inner city environment. And more surprising still was the fact that I discovered it hidden away in the heavily built-up area close to our hotel.
I’ve already mentioned the church with blue domes next to the main road opposite my bedroom window. But it was only on that final day that I ventured to investigate what lay behind it and discovered an authentic village totally enclosed in a tract of virtual countryside so large that (once entered) the illusion of being in a faraway rural environment was almost complete.
It was here, as far as I recall, that I had my first glimpse of detached houses in single occupation. Many were wooden and rather tumbledown; but at least they were traditional - the sort of thing I’d long wanted to see. There was washing on the line; there were figs and vegetables in the gardens; and the hilltop above the village was occupied by a picturesque cemetery set within ancient walls where there was a chapel, a well and a cottage. Unfortunately, however, there was also evidence of a very aggressive-sounding dog which persuaded me to probe no further.
And yet, in an altogether different vein, in the safer surroundings outside the cemetery gates, two boys were shaking the walnuts somewhat prematurely out of a tree - whilst a teenage couple, further downhill, gave me an embarrassed look as they sauntered hand-in-hand out of a shady lane before disappearing conspiratorially into another. And amazingly (it only occurred to me afterwards), the equivalent area in London would have been close to the British Museum.
This was my last experience of sightseeing before we all packed our bags in readiness to move on from Kishinyev. And I’m fairly certain that, having discovered the improbable backwaters that the other group members missed, I took a brighter picture away with me than they did. And so it is that the church with the blue domes, and what lay behind it, is just one among a number of vivid memories that were (and still remain) so unforgettable.
​
A CROSS-COUNTRY RIDE
On the following morning, our departure for Odessa (back in the Ukraine) was by coach. And Antonia - our permanent mentor who provided continuity against the background of the local guides - seemed conscious of the fact that no one was sorry we were leaving.
As things turned out, it was a three-hour journey of disappointingly little interest: the encounters at Bendery have been mentioned already; and the outskirts of Tiraspol displayed no enticements. The countryside too, apart from one forested ridge, was below par. In addition to which, none of the villages had much character; and the arable landscape was too much like similar areas in flattish, equally drab locations in England. Consequently, although there were high hopes for Odessa (we’d heard a lot about it), there was also widespread snoozing aboard the coach as we advanced towards our destination on the historic shores of the Black Sea​.
ODESSA
Odessa, on the north-west coast of the Black Sea, was our second visit to the Ukraine; and, from the local guide’s account, we promptly encountered sombre and unforgiven memories of the Nazi occupation. This included the terrible loss of life, the destruction of property, and the heroic stand of the partisans operating from a hideout in the catacombs beyond the city limits. Important and touching reminders of these tumultuous events will be described in greater detail later on. But the fact that such material formed part of the welcome on arrival at our latest destination was a clear sign of the marks left behind by history.
* * *
Prominent in our minds nowadays, of course, is the importance attached by the former USSR to this part of the Ukraine - in particular to the emphasis laid on the Crimean coast and its vital strategic significance. Nor will many people have forgotten that, only a few years ago, the flames of conflict were ignited when a large part of the territory was annexed by the government of modern Russia. This naturally led to an international outcry; but happily, the furore occurred many years after our 1991 visit which was therefore unaffected.
Odessa’s less controversial claim to fame, also a spin-off inherited from Soviet times, was its function as a holiday resort whose several stretches of beach lay alongside a wooded coastal strip. Further inland, as we’d already seen from the coach, the flat countryside was unremarkable and hardly likely to lure us away from the far greater attractions awaiting us in the city. More crucial, however, and speaking for myself alone, if I’d wanted a holiday centred on sun, sand and a deckchair, I’d have chosen the far more restful environment of the beaches on the Dnieper islands next door to Kiev.
​​​
THE HOTEL
For some of us - myself included - the conveniently placed Intourist Hotel on the corner of Ulitsa Lenina, looked like an improvement on recent disappointments. The lobby was bustling, the gift shop was modestly stocked, liquor and a few cosmetics were available for hard currency; and the postal counter was staffed by a cheerful young woman who augmented her job description by directing two Jewish members of our group to a synagogue. Relief was also felt on arrival when, after enquiries, Antonia confirmed the availability of hot water which (sticking to plain facts) was actually lukewarm, light brown, and as cold as ice by the third and final morning!
Nevertheless, I was broadly satisfied with my room. The upbeat view across the roofs and treetops took in a strip of sea - whilst the foreground was enlivened by a church with two sets of promisingly oversize onion domes. The bathroom was also larger and in a far better state than the Kishinyev experience - although there were cement patches on the ceiling; and the washbasin leaked water on to the tiled floor from which it escaped down a conveniently positioned drain.
Unfortunately, the other guests fared less well than I did with such extreme reports of cockroach infestation that rooms had to be changed several times over: one couple even offered to pay extra to stay in another hotel. And in my own case, I have to confess to stamping on five small cockroaches in the bathroom before going to bed on the second night.
* * *
Food continued to be adequate for some of us but uneatable for the majority. By this time, fed up with the monotony and exacerbated by the cockroach situation, perfectly reasonable meals were pushed aside in favour of cold snacks and suchlike purchased elsewhere. On one occasion, for example, many people rejected the offer of braised steak - although in reality, it was unusually palatable, and would have passed muster as a native dish on any British dinner table. At the same time, a small tomato cut into quarters and topped with a single parsley leaf was lampooned as a truly mindless attempt at a breakfast starter - particularly when followed by a cold and pallor-stricken fried egg.
By this stage in our tour, the dilemma had persuaded many people to experiment with the local restaurants; and this proved a very successful manoeuvre. Necessity is the mother of invention; and in the dire circumstances facing us, anyone with a tendency to culinary xenophobia certainly managed to overcome it. Lacking any such prejudice myself, I was therefore delighted to accompany a group of about eight people to Odessa’s Retro restaurant where the first course consisted of three cold meats and a salad with red and black caviar. This was followed by veal and chips, and finished with some excellent ice cream. Not forgetting four bottles of Russian champagne and four cans of lager - plus coffee - we paid the equivalent of two pounds forty-five pence each, including the tip and a live band in the background.
It was a great discovery and a memorable evening out - although one mustn’t forget it was a feast that would not only have been mouth-watering for an ordinary local inhabitant, but also an eye-opener when one considers the damage it would have done to an average pay packet. It’s also worth remembering that we too were ‘ordinary people’ who, by a mere throw of the dice, happened to be sufficiently well heeled to think it was cheap.
THE CITY
Following the wartime destruction, as we’d already noticed elsewhere, newly constructed buildings reflected a stark, deadpan tradition modified on occasion by a certain southerly, turn-of-the-century look which was augmented by a number of edifices with surviving, nineteenth century origins. Furthermore, the height of major properties was generally less overwhelming than in some of the other places we’d visited; and this created a more people-friendly atmosphere - although many façades were in need of a ‘wash and brush-up’.
The leaf canopy throughout the centre of Odessa seemed particularly dense, creating contrasts of light and shade inimical to routine holiday photography. Furthermore, towards evening, the avenues of planes darkened perceptibly as vast flocks of rooks wheeled and circled into town from the surrounding countryside to roost among the branches.
I discovered no unexpected, village-like areas in Odessa such as those I’d stumbled on elsewhere. At the same time, I found that many buildings in the central areas - whether commercial or domestic - were constructed on a rectangular grid that incorporated a somewhat lightless inner courtyard accessible from the street through an archway. These complexes were often in multistorey occupation as flats accompanied by external stairs, washing on the lines, and a medley of rusting playground contraptions. They looked very run down indeed and were sometimes situated behind even the most august façades that featured, for example, a stylish bookshop, a small department store, a café or a butcher. It was an interesting way of mixing people and business activity in a virtually symbiotic relationship. On the other hand, at the time of our visit, I couldn’t help noticing the contrast between the commercially developed fronts and the residential backs - to the obvious disadvantage of the latter.
* * *
Despite the negative features so far outlined, Odessa was a long way ahead of Kishinyev simply in terms of its relaxing atmosphere. Although certain areas were poorly maintained, there was also a strong urban character refreshingly enhanced by a variety of sea views. The department store facing the hotel admittedly had little to offer apart from long-playing records at about sixteen pence each. On the other hand, at the opposite end of Ulitsa Lenina, the concentration of highlights confirmed it was ‘the place to be’.
Starting from the enormous and opulent Opera House - which is world-famous - and the cluster of museums around it, I enjoyed sauntering past the Pushkin Memorial and along leafy Ulitsa Suborova to Potemkin Steps at the base of which, if I’d wanted to, I could have joined other tourists on a Black Sea pleasure boat.
More interesting, however, were the steps themselves; named after the famous battleship that shelled Odessa in 1905, they’d been designed to counter the narrowing effects of perspective for visitors looking down from the highest point towards sea level - an effect brought about by progressively widening the steps in proportion to the increase in distance from the top.
In addition to the pleasant sea views visible from Potemkin Steps, there was (as elsewhere) no shortage of young men selling postcards and military watches. There was also a sizeable group of portrait artists whose friendliness towards tourists went hand in hand with an obvious desire to generate business. Such widespread private enterprise had clearly been going on for longer than the short period since the recent political changes; strictly speaking, therefore, it must have been illegal. When asked later on, however, our local guide pointed out that the authorities had been obliged to ignore it since to do otherwise would have meant arresting half the population!
A Casual Walkabout
Given my personal priorities alongside the fact that, in Odessa, we were left largely to our own devices, there was little time to investigate the museums. Nevertheless, I managed a lightening visit to the Opera House (Academy of Theatre, Opera & Ballet) in Ulitsa Lastochkina. Here I was greatly impressed by a building which had been restored after the end of World War II - with the result that, for the second time in its life, it was a magnificent, ornate extravaganza featuring a wide variety of coloured marbles and more than a kilo of gold leaf. I’d never before seen such an enormous proscenium arch - and the following evening, with other members of the group, I attended a superb English-language performance of Othello. I was also pleasantly surprised on discovering that the ticket for the sixth row of the stalls at five roubles amounted to a very competitive ten pence sterling.
Moving on from the Opera House, and battling through yet more clusters of youths selling Gorby dolls, lacquer boxes and military caps, I reached Ulitsa Dyeribasovskaya two blocks away. This was a long, reassuringly attractive avenue of stores and cafés lying at the heart of the city - just the right spot, I thought, for strutting about and absorbing the local atmosphere. I also noticed there was a larger number of bookstores than I’d observed anywhere else. Generally speaking, however, there wasn’t much (apart from souvenirs) to persuade foreign visitors to part with their dollars or roubles.
Despite this mild deficiency, there were other intriguing sides to life in Ulitsa Dyeribasovskaya: the crowds out walking and eating ice cream provided much local colour; there was a restful little park with fountains; and there was also an international-style hustle and bustle. This included unexpectedly familiar features such as the pop group I watched performing at the kerbside. And for me at least, the number of onlookers and the cheerful tenor of the music suggested that the entertainers were cashing in on the still mesmerising novelty of uncensored self-expression.
The Free Market
The special nature of free markets has already been emphasised in the course of this story. Nevertheless, it’s worth mentioning the largest of them all which I discovered at the southern end of Ulitsa Lenina close to Odessa’s main railway station. The ground area must have been five times that of Old Covent Garden in the West End of London. And the goods, as always, were mainly fresh vegetables. There were, however, many more prepared products than elsewhere such as the huge piles of shredded and oiled carrot, a greater variety of sausages and also some handicrafts including good basketry. Flowers were as ubiquitous as ever; but a very different feature compared with the other markets I’d visited was the number of vendors (mostly women) of Central Asian appearance. All of them were wearing brightly coloured headscarves; and a keen photographer could easily have spent a whole day in this partly covered market where, to add to the variety, even freshly killed geese were on sale - for those with enough money to pay for them!
A Sobering Experience
Wandering on from the market area and the railway station, I approached Privokzalnaya Ploshchad which was overlooked by the silver domes of a former cathedral which had been converted into a planetarium. And it was here that I encountered a sight that gave me genuine pause for thought.
It was an established fact, of course, that during our tour so far, we’d all encountered touts quite frequently - but few beggars. In and around the Privokzalnaya Ploshchad underpass, however, there were no street traders at all; but instead, I came across many senior citizens in a worse state than I’d seen anywhere else. Looking back, one has to admit the futility of continually restating one’s surprise at finding such destitution in a country formerly extolled as a people’s paradise; but I do feel that due tribute must be paid to the elderly woman I saw sitting half asleep on a wall in the full heat of the sun. With bruises all the way down the side of one leg, she seemed quite indifferent to the open sore on her ankle which was obscured by a mass of ‘bluebottle’ flies and a wasp. This public spectacle drew me to an abrupt halt; and the photograph I felt it reasonable to take without the sitter’s knowledge was suitably paid for after I’d waited until she opened her eyes and could actually see what was happening.
THE MARKS OF WARFARE
The coastal strip flanking Odessa on its east-facing side was an area several kilometres in length that consisted of refreshingly green parkland and shady woods. At the northern extreme, given the amount of sightseeing I’d indulged in, 1 was therefore delighted to find a quietness that answered to a powerful urge. This enabled me to sit down on a sunny promontory overlooking the sea whilst listening to the sound of music from a passing pleasure cruiser. It also enabled me to contemplate the ‘cabbage white’ butterflies as they flapped, with typical indecision, in and out of the flower beds.
Close to this pleasant spot there was an open square approached by a broad avenue descending through the trees towards the sea where there was an obelisk of considerable size commemorating Odessa’s dead under the Nazi occupation. This is not a history book, and I cannot recall the exact statistics; but what I do remember is enough to confirm the terror suffered by the many inhabitants who were killed as well as by the lucky ones who survived.
In the main, however, it was in memory of those who died that this sea-facing cenotaph had been erected; and it was to the same end that it was still honoured every day by a detachment of boys and girls in marine uniforms from the nearby academy. In orderly goose-step formation, starting just before noon, they paraded along the lengthy approach to the memorial which they reached promptly as the hour struck. And the solemn symphonic music played on loudspeakers, the touching sight of such very young people wordlessly caught up in their ancestral trauma added something especially striking to my one-man expedition. It was a spectacle that remains with me still, despite the passage of time. And the brightness of the day, the natural surroundings, and the innocence of the young in the context of a bloodbath helped to hammer home what the Ukrainians and the Russians alike had had to put up with during the Second World War.
The Catacombs
Our last afternoon in Odessa proved exceptionally rewarding - although for reasons I cannot remember, it was also one of the few organised trips provided by Intourist in that city. At the same time, it was a genuine high point that gave us a vivid, almost first-hand picture of the hardship and endurance of the population during World War II; on top of which it enabled us to experience literally what it was like to be on the inside of a surviving remnant of the reality itself. And finally, to give credit where it’s due, it’s worth pointing out that our guide’s introduction, as summarised below, added a great deal to our interest and understanding.
* * *
Following the German army’s occupation of the city, and after the defending forces had secretly escaped in advance of the seizure, organised groups of partisans continued to harass the enemy. And the reason they managed to hold on for a very long time was because, in more senses than one, they went ‘under ground’ in order to escape annihilation and remain active. This was a wise and bold strategy, enabling them to emerge at night and engage in guerilla warfare: the secret being that, during the day, they remained concealed in the labyrinthine catacombs situated about fourteen kilometres away from the city.
The extensive network of tunnels was not a natural phenomenon; instead, it was the remains of a century or more of quarrying the marine rock needed for house-building. The Germans, we were told, were never entirely successful in flushing out their adversaries - nor, apparently, were they aware that all the original entry points had been blocked and replaced by a substitute means of entry they never knew existed. By the time of our visit, of course, easy access had been re-established - and so it was that, in 1991, we had the privilege of exploring several hundred metres of the dark underground world where dedicated fighters, young and old, had held out during the occupation.
Once inside, the continuing presence of the past was evident all around us - despite the introduction of electric lighting which the wartime defenders had wisely steered clear of. Many of the original furnishings and fittings were still in place: there was a kitchen with the oven cut into the rock; there was also a field hospital consisting of a pair of iron bedsteads in an antechamber; and in the officers’ quarters, some of the original books accompanied by an ancient wind-up gramophone remained exactly where they’d been since the end of hostilities. It was a genuine hotchpotch of evocative leftovers quietly at ease in the company of the lingering ghosts. And in particular, there was a well shaft slicing through a tunnel which had been used to pass messages in and out of the underground system by means of the false bottom in a bucket. Beyond doubt, therefore - at least for some of us - it was an exciting reminder of the many much admired, black-and-white war films we’d watched when we were considerably younger than we were in the summer of 1991.
* * *
I indulged just one last, marginally negative reflection on this intriguing wartime venue that shared so much common ground with other countries involved in the battles of the Second World War. Both as a national memorial and as a tourist attraction, I simply felt it was under-exploited as an enterprise. An attempt to remedy this had already been made by building a second-rate museum; but after encountering just a little of the reality beneath my feet, I considered that a pair of glass cabinets with a few photographs of the partisans was hardly enough. A first-class museum complex under expert supervision - with the addition of good local research - would have been ideal as well as a possible source of revenue. At the time of our visit, however, there were just two desks selling tin medals and some postcards; and there were no refreshments. On the other hand, as a fleeting visitor from abroad, I tried to be more positive. After all, I told myself, it was early days; it had also been a uniquely rewarding visit. And as we drove off and made our way back to the hotel, I felt just a trace of sadness when I considered the fact that, after breakfast the following morning, we’d be leaving Odessa behind us.
FLYING NORTH
Our expectations were high; and we were all ready to make a move - even before breakfast was over. It was the final moment; and few of my compatriots seemed to share my sudden sadness at having to say goodbye. Instead, their concentration was focussed exclusively on what was coming next: by which I mean a city that was still known to the world as Leningrad. At the same time, of course, despite lingering reservations, I shared their enthusiasm for what lay ahead. And that, despite the attractions of Odessa, was more or less that.
There was no room for shilly-shallying, however, when the coach taking us to the airport left the hotel earlier than strictly necessary. This was a considered move on the part of Antonia as a means of dodging possible snags which, happily, never materialised. After all, she said, the trip to Leningrad would take more than two hours; and having to wait for a later flight would seriously disrupt the schedule.
Once airborne, the journey was smooth and uneventful: the in-flight refreshments were as dreadful as ever; and the increasing cloud cover not only obscured the landscape but also reminded me that, in late August, we were exchanging the near-mediterranean climate of the Black Sea for a latitude abreast of Oslo and Alaska. And so, with Odessa behind us and Leningrad ahead of us, all we could do was to sit back, relax... and hope for the best when we reached our final and, with luck, our most rewarding destination.
ST PETERSBURG
The airport was at some distance from the city. And after touchdown, the weather that greeted the trippers on the tarmac was wet, grey and chilly - very British in fact; and very British some of my compatriots looked, too, with their hitherto undisclosed plastic macs and fold-up umbrellas! But the holiday experience was about to surprise everyone. Neither we nor the world at large was yet aware of the imminent changes to the city’s status; the airport duty-free shop was more sensational than anything anyone had seen since arrival in Moscow; and there was an English-language advertisement on display inviting travellers to sample the Indian restaurant.
The first thing everyone did was to descend on the duty-free shop with a view to some basic luxuries such as bottled water without an unpleasant taste, or a bag of toffees. Personally, I went a little further than the welcome luxury of two fruit-and-nut bars by investing in cigars and vodka as well; but at several times its street value, I steered clear of the caviar.
Finally, before quitting the airport, the fried chicken lunch in the spacious dining area was well above average - although to place it on a par with Odessa’s Retro restaurant would have been an overstatement. On the other hand, after comparing it with what our new hosts were about to serve us with, it was truly exceptional.
AN UNEXPECTED PREVIEW
​
The local guide who joined us on the coach for the trip from the airport into town was at first difficult to understand due to her strong accent. She was a kindly woman - somewhat forlorn perhaps, and a little over-made-up. Nevertheless, she earned everyone’s sympathy and admiration for the highly detailed account she gave us of the city’s past history and current conditions. We were also grateful for her thoroughness, bearing in mind that she found it hard to keep going at so great a length in English. Despite which, such was her grasp of facts and figures that, using a pocket recorder, I decided to preserve an account of what she had to tell us during the long drive into the city which culminated later on at the Hotel Moskva.
Siege of Leningrad
The German Siege of Leningrad, we were told, lasted nine hundred days in all - during which time there was widespread destruction of property due to the shelling which also accounted for seventeen thousand deaths. This total was outstripped, however, by the effects of starvation at a time when the daily bread ration could be as little as a few grammes a day. Deaths from this cause alone exceeded the effects of the shelling and amounted to over six hundred and fifty thousand men, women and children.
By leaping directly from the foregoing into a critical account of current conditions, our guide made it clear that the people’s endurance had so far received scant recompense. Among other things, she cited the crash building programme to rehouse everybody in one-room flats. These, she declared, had become the norm for the entire population - meaning that, in practice, there were several families, each occupying single rooms, on every floor of the municipal blocks with only one kitchen and bathroom per storey between them! Such was the state of affairs that, despite a plan to provide a separate flat for each family by the year 2005, the divorce rate in the city was one in two. Furthermore, births were dropping sharply because (in our guide’s view) people were simply unwilling to procreate under such circumstances. It was a ferocious indictment; and for relatively well-off westerners in 1991, it was difficult to believe.
* * *
We were already well acquainted with the fact that food was rationed throughout the country. For example, I’d observed long bread queues in Kiev and had noted that, however long it took to acquire, each person emerged from the shop with nothing more than a single loaf. Our guide now told us that the monthly allocation of meat was one and a half kilos - which boiled down to about fifty grammes a day. I can no longer recall whether this figure was per person or per family; but whatever the truth of the matter, for those of us who can get through, say, two sausages and two rashers of bacon for breakfast - not to mention the bread, marmalade and coffee - the information was very hard indeed to assimilate.
Something in the Air
In the midst of this depressing account of past and present hardships, our guide was suddenly alerted to the fact that the driver wanted a word with her; and after a short, visibly animated conversation, we all realised there was something in the air. She then resumed her introductory talk with a much brighter expression on her face. And there was a very good reason for it: namely, that while the driver was listening to the radio, he’d heard the amazing news that, by official decree, the city’s name had been changed; with the result that now, after a virtual lifetime, Leningrad was once again to be known as St Petersburg.
This was sensational news! Everyone on board clapped enthusiastically whilst some of them gasped... and our guide looked radiant. She also looked more relaxed: it was as if, at last, she’d got used to us. And so, by way of celebration, she had what I suspect was a ready-made joke to tell about the chronic conditions in her native country. It concerned the allegation that even if one had the money for a private car, it would take ten years to get it. Here is the gist of the joke.
A young man acquired sufficient funds to buy a car and went along to the appropriate state office to place his order. The official offered him a form which took a long time to complete - after which the young man handed it back to be checked. This again took some time to accomplish, given the endless uncertainties; and there was further prolonged to’ing and fro’ing between various drawers and files.
The clerk was a by no means insensitive person; and it was without any sort of rancour (he was unable to afford a car himself) that he explained to the intending purchaser that he would have to wait ten years.
‘Will delivery be in the morning or the afternoon?’ asked the young man.
‘What the hell does it matter’ answered the clerk ‘when we’re talking about the year 2001?’
‘It’s essential I take delivery in the morning’ came the reply. ‘I have a plumber booked for the same day in the afternoon!’
HOTEL MOSKVA
As we approached the end of our drive from the airport to the Hotel Moskva - and having so far listened with interest to the points our guide felt we should know - one of my fellow travellers mentioned that, according to her Intourist leaflet, the hotel was sited on the corner of Alexander Nevsky Ploshchad; and since she’d often noticed this name in the course of our tour, she thought it might be interesting to understand the background.
Our guide was more than willing to oblige, and explained that, in Russia, Alexander Nevsky was a very big name. Born in the year 1220, he was Prince of Novgorod from 1236 - his critical claim to fame being that, in 1240, he defeated the Swedes on the banks of the River Neva (which happens to cut through St Petersburg). He died in 1263, and left an undying name behind him. He was subsequently canonised by the church and, as our guide went on to inform us, he was still revered as a saint by believers and by non-believers (even by the communists) as a national hero.
* * *
Having left the coach, and excited by the news we’d just heard on board, we began to take an interest in our latest hotel; and to begin with, the signs looked promising. The entrance lobby had an excellent hard currency shop (assuming visitors were prepared to pay high prices for the familiar-looking foreign goods or the better-than-usual Russian crafts). In addition to this, the entire area was more spacious and contained many more facilities than we’d encountered previously.
Enough has been said already about hotels in the course of this story; although it remained a matter of concern for all of us as we gradually built up a picture of the latest example. To be fair, the building and the shops passed muster; and the dining room décor also stood up to critical inspection. On the other hand, the food was probably the most unpalatable and the coldest of the entire trip. On top of this, the fact that the waiters were selling tins of caviar privately at twice the street value was the first sign of a downward spiral. It was painfully obvious, for example, that they were more concerned about their under-the-counter sales than they were about serving the food - so much so that, on the very first evening, several of us got up and helped ourselves from the unattended trolleys.
Despite all this, with the country in the state it was, I felt that some of my British companions from conspicuously ordinary backgrounds might have suppressed their anger which caused mature staff to blush without any attempt at retaliation. As waiters, they were almost certainly underpaid and well aware that their performance was a shambles. I therefore felt that instead of being treated like nonentities, they could perhaps have been nudged into modest reductions in the price of the caviar.
* * *
Lastly, on the subject of hotels, I have to be truthful: for there was yet more bad news for anyone hoping for an improvement on past experience. The bedrooms, viewed purely as functional spaces with a wardrobe, a chest of drawers and a bed, were passable; and the absence of cockroaches was a bonus. On the other hand, I remember that the bath water, after running it for five minutes in an attempt to clear it, was such a deep chocolate brown that the bottom of the bath and the plug hole vanished almost immediately after turning the tap on! So having braved a similar situation in Kishinyev, I was now face to face with something even worse on the last lap of the tour.
THE CITY
It would be over-ambitious and ultimately futile to attempt an exhaustive description of St Petersburg within the limits of a journey from one end of Russia to the other - a journey, moreover, compressed into a mere fourteen days. The inevitable result being that the time spent in each location was always too short - and nowhere more so than in St Petersburg. Consider the following comparison. To arrive in London, to visit the Tower and stroll along Oxford Street, to board a tourist bus for a quick look at St Paul’s and the Houses of Parliament from the outside - plus two hours at Tate Britain and a half-day trip to Windsor - all of this would be quite an achievement crammed into little more than a long weekend. And even if it were possible, it would be about as unrepresentative of the quality and quantity of the British capital’s attractions as was my short-lived encounter with the variety and splendour of Russia’s second city. I can safely say, however, that any readers thinking of visiting Russia nowadays would be spending their money to good effect if they decided to concentrate, say, on a week in St Petersburg.
* * *
As the foregoing introduction implies, I was very impressed with what little I managed to fit in whilst exploring St Petersburg; and although volumes have been written already about what is an internationally acknowledged artistic and architectural gem, I do feel it’s important emphasise the vastness of the open spaces within its confines. Tsar Peter the Great who founded the city as a bastion against the Swedes, naturally had the necessary power and resources. He was greatly assisted, however, by the considerable width of the River Neva (and its many branches) as it made its way to the Baltic at the northern extreme of the city. Moreover, during several centuries of development, broad canals linking the various divisions of this impressive waterway have been added and have led to the description of St Petersburg as the Venice of the North.
The river therefore furnishes the grandest of vistas as a backdrop to St Petersburg’s many architectural features. The view upstream across the Bolshaya Neva to the Peter & Paul Fortress is especially emotive if viewed from Dvortsovy Most. Indeed, when I first caught sight of it, a grey drizzle was softening the strip of yellow sunlight torn out of a cloud and setting fire to the gilded weather vane at the apex of the building. The Hermitage Museum & Art Gallery is likewise enhanced when viewed from across the river; although, at the time of our visit, it looked a little shabby but still imposing in its external mantle of mid green and white. And Dvortsovaya Ploshchad, the open square behind it, is more than big enough to engulf Trafalgar Square several times over.
The Hermitage
I visited The Hermitage art museum on my own. Unfortunately, however, closing time was imminent; and in consequence, I was unable to linger as long as I would have liked in a venue whose displays, as I later found out, included collections first introduced by Catherine the Great. Despite the limited time, I was nevertheless lucky enough to catch a temporary exhibition of Greek and Balkan icons; and I followed this up with a brief look at the museum’s selection of impressionist and post-impressionist paintings. Among those on show, I was particularly struck by Van Gogh’s 1899 close-up of a bush in full bloom that was miraculously transformed from its native light-saturated ordinariness into an enchanting amalgam of greens and yellows pulsating with energy. It was as memorable for its quiet beauty as it was for the unembroidered nature of its title which, bereft of all frills, was simply ‘Lilacs’.
That painting remains a poignant memory compared to which, for me, the grand galleries and elegant staircases have faded somewhat with the passage of time. And lastly, just one more, minor footnote is worth mentioning to the following effect: namely, that I’d never before realised that The Hermitage and The Winter Palace were part and parcel of the same complex of buildings. And so, as my brief visit ended, I not only felt uplifted - but also better informed.
Petropavlovskaya
For many of us, one of the most interesting events during our stay in St Petersburg was an organised trip to the Peter & Paul Fortress - known in Russian as Petropavlovskaya. According to the guide, it was originally built as a defence against the Swedes; and as we soon discovered after arrival, it incorporated a magnificent cathedral containing the tombs of several Tsars. Most spectacular among these was the polished sarcophagus of Alexander II which took seventeen years to carve from a single slab of Altai jasper weighing five tons. Further to which, his wife followed suit, but broke her hsband’s record with a sarcophagus carved from a piece of Urals rhondonite weighing even more at well over six tons!
Our guide also pointed out a more recent historical contribution made by the Peter & Paul Fortress: for it was from there, in 1917, that a message was sent to the battleship Aurora moored in the Neva, ordering it to fire on the Winter Palace where the provisional government was holed up. The sympathetic crew mutinied, murdered the commanding officer who tried to stop them, and formed an on-board revolutionary committee. Shortly after this, an appeal from Lenin ‘to the citizens of Russia’ was transmitted by radio from the ship; and at about 21.40 on the twenty-fifth of October 1917, a crew member, gunner Yevgeny Ognev, fired the single shot which, according to reports, was the final signal for the storming of the Winter Palace.
Nevsky Prospekt
No one is likely to visit St Petersburg without taking a turn along the principal shopping boulevard, Nevsky Prospekt, which is over three kilometres in length from the Admiralty at one end to the Moskva Railway Station at the opposite extreme. A further, less interesting kilometre of Nevsky Prospekt then passes close to an important monastery, to be mentioned again later, which has survived a great deal of past tribulation and which, without our knowing it, was in the news at the time of our tour.
For eager tourists like me and the rest of the group, Nevsky Prospekt failed to provide much more in the way of shopping opportunities than the other places we’d so far visited. On the other hand, for those who were really determined, this wasn’t quite true. Unfortunately, however, and still on the negative side, the main and absolutely vast department store was reminiscent of the covered market in London’s Brixton - although, by contrast with the latter, it stocked almost nothing with a genuinely practical use. With the result that the chief image I took away with me was that of a long line of women selling single pairs of second-hand shoes in the hopes of making a small profit.
On the positive side, however, Nevsky Prospekt was also home to several presentable bookshops. Some of these included art departments where souvenirs and gifts were of a much higher standard than we’d found elsewhere - and the prices were infinitesimal compared with the hard currency shops. For example, I obtained three beautifully crafted and painted Russian Easter eggs for just over two pounds each and a charming set of miniature oil paintings selling at roughly the same price.
* * *
Generally speaking, the best bargains in Russia were in St Petersburg, and the best bargains in St Petersburg were on the streets. I therefore found myself considering some exquisitely painted lacquer boxes for between twenty-four and forty-two pounds on wayside stalls compared with similar items at up to three hundred pounds in the hard currency shops. I also obtained two small bottles of authentic Russian vodka that would have cost unbelievably more in London’s West End. And finally, Russian dolls - each of the series fitting inside the next largest - were at their very best in St Petersburg in terms of their traditional decorative motifs and sensitively selected colours.
In the end, therefore, I found Nevsky Prospekt both interesting and very much alive - even in the rain. And although I had so little time, the network of canals, each cutting through the tangle of streets, provided intriguing and elegant architectural enticements to areas well off the beaten track. Particularly grand was the ornate and colourful church mysteriously dedicated to ‘The Saviour on (the Field of) Spilled Blood’. Unfortunately, despite trying, I’ve never managed to confirm the true form or significance of this title; for example, could it possibly be a reference to - Golgotha? Equally intriguing but less perplexing was the discovery that the church had been extended in such a way as to incorporate within its walls the exact spot where Tsar Alexander II alighted from his coach and was assassinated on the thirteenth of March 1881.
Also of interest, back on Nevsky Prospekt, was the Cathedral of Our Lady of Kazan whose name refers to one of the Orthodox Church’s most venerated icons which, by tradition, is housed in the Monastery of the Mother of God in the city of Kazan - a city that lies far away beside the Volga to the east of Nizhni Novgorod.
St Isaak’s Cathedral
Looking back at our stay in St Petersburg, I now realise I spent far more time than my fellow tourists exploring on my own - partly because their interests and mine tended to differ and partly because I was travelling unaccompanied and therefore able to break free from the encumbrance of conflicting preferences. But that certainly didn’t mean I missed any of the organised tours; and prominent among these was a visit to St Isaak’s cathedral in Isaakiyevskaya Ploshchad.
At that time, although about to reopen as a church, it was still being officially described as a ‘history museum’. And it was soon more than clear that our guide was very proud of it as a structure. According to his somewhat ardent testimony, it was the biggest cathedral in the world after St Peters in Rome, London’s St Paul’s and St Mark’s, Venice. The mighty dome, he added, had recently been regilded after having been painted grey during the Leningrad siege in order to reduce the temptation of the Germans (then just outside the city) to use it for target practice.
Once inside, we discovered an interior aglow with coloured marbles which, for me at least, greatly outshone what I still regard as the heaviness - even dullness - of St Paul’s in London. The elaborate iconostasis (a screen, characteristic of Orthodox churches) separated the sanctuary from the nave; and with its doors slightly ajar, we were able to see a vast, stained glass window depicting Christ at the far end.
Our guide, still very much enthused, then smuggled us surreptitiously through the doors and into what, at least in theory, was ‘sacred space’. For unfamiliar visitors like us, of course, it seemed a somewhat presumptuous gesture; on the other hand, it provided us with a glimpse of what it must once have been like to be present at the heart of the liturgy - an experience from which, even today, congregations are excluded while the priests, in a very real sense, re-enact the Last Supper in splendid isolation.
Before accompanying us back to the hotel, our guide had one final, somewhat obscure news item in store for us: namely, the proposition that St Isaak’s was the only cathedral in Russia with a pulpit - a feature attributable to the fact that the architect had originally come from Italy where all the churches have a pulpit - as they do just as commonly in England and everywhere else in western Christendom.
I couldn’t help feeling, however, that in all probability, one or two of my fellow travellers had never seen the inside of a church before they landed in Russia where, unlike churches in the West, sermons are preached standing at ground level on the sanctuary steps rather than from a specially built structure.
THE ALEXANDER NEVSKY LAVRA
Although hidden from direct view, the Alexander Nevsky Lavra was situated opposite the Moskva Hotel where we were staying - a circumstance that would shortly contribute much drama in the eyes of a group of unsuspecting tourists such as ourselves. Looking back, it was also a remarkable coincidence that what happened took place so soon after the change of name from Leningrad to St Petersburg. And stranger still was the fact that, had it not been for my interest in the Russian Orthodox church, none of us would have stumbled on an event which, to say the least, was dramatic both in its own right and in terms of the particular date and timing of its occurrence.
* * *
During our first evening at Hotel Moskva, most of us assembled for dinner in the street-level dining room where the windows looked out across the main thoroughfare and provided a view of the buildings opposite - buildings that incorporated a stone archway leading directly to the monastery and its cathedral church which, without walking through the arch and along a winding footpath, was completely hidden. It goes without saying, of course, that having arrived at the hotel only recently, plus the time spent on the city tour, none of us had so far found an opportunity for exploring the local environment.
By this point in our visit to Russia, I’d become part of a small number of people who, as time wore on, had fallen into the habit of gathering as a group for meals. I’ve now forgotten who most of them were. However, I do recall two middle-aged couples with whom I got on particularly well: firstly, David and Ruth from Fortis Green in North London; and secondly, Desmond and his wife Joyce from Lyndhurst in Hampshire. Lyndhurst along with the nearby village of Bartley were Where my mother was born and bred - a factor, no doubt, that played its part in promoting a cordial relationship.
My seat at table meant that, during the conversation, I was able to look through the windows at the still undiscovered world beyond. My scrutiny was superficial, however, and my main focus was on what people were talking about; but I clearly remember noticing it was busier on the far side of the road than on the near side - although, at first, this didn’t seem significant. All the same, after we’d finished our rather unremarkable evening meal, I left the others to their own devices; and being increasingly curious about our new location, I decided to take a stroll. And once outside, of course, it was much easier to appreciate that the activity on the far side of the road was due to the large number of people to’ing-and-fro’ing through the archway for some special reason which, as things stood, was far from obvious.
Driven by natural curiosity about a circumstance that lacked an explanation, I therefore crossed the road to see for myself what was afoot - although, to begin with, I was reluctant to abandon the bright lights of the public highway en route to a questionable journey’s end. I pressed on, however; and having followed the crowd and turned a corner, I was eventually relieved to discover we were approaching what I soon found out was a cathedral - a cathedral, moreover, of unique importance both to the country in general and to a significant number of its people.
The Heart of Russian Culture
Now that I could see where I was going, I gradually became aware of a choir singing within the confines of what sounded like a vast empty space; and yet, despite the consequent hollowness, it was clearly characteristic of Russian church music which is exclusively choral and yet endowed with the richness associated with an instrumental accompaniment. This effect, however, is achieved solely by the harmonious combination and varying pitch of the singers’ voices. And so, with rising enthusiasm, and given my special interest, I found myself gathering pace as I approached the door - although there was no need to have hurried, for I was about to witness a highly charged ceremony which, as I eventually discovered, was still far from its conclusion.
Unlike some parts of the world where, as a foreigner, one is immediately noticed, in St Petersburg... in the cathedral of St Alexander Nevsky... it was easy to melt into the crowd and absorb the spectacle - and spectacle really was the right word. There was the sheer volume of space - although any hint of emptiness was countered by the number of people present. Furthermore, there was the additional sense of movement running alongside the service because, apart from the old or infirm, Russian congregations habitually stand without necessarily standing still. And this enables anyone who so wishes to visit the many icons whilst, at the same time, keeping abreast of the liturgy.
To begin with, of course, I was gripped by the many competing points of interest. For example, some of the paintings and icons were among the most evocative and visually opulent of the entire tour; and votive lamps were burning everywhere - their flames glimmering through the red, blue and green glass vessels containing them. Moreover, as if this wasn’t enough, there was also the sharp, sweet-smelling tang of incense adrift in the air - in addition to which there were two choirs rather than one - the first standing on the sanctuary steps and the second on the balcony above the cathedral’s main entrance.
* * *
These were my first, random impressions - memorable impressions, too, that formed a vivid backdrop to what was clearly a celebration of some sort - although, as I looked and listened, the precise nature of the event remained a mystery. Mystery or no mystery, however, for the first time since leaving London, I felt I was as close as I was ever likely to get to the heart of Russian culture. It was an indefinable but very particular sort of feeling.
It was also a perception for which there was much supporting evidence. Starting with the sheer scale of the building, every detail was magnificent. And whilst I stood there fully engrossed, a group of several priests (surrounded on three sides by the congregation) gathered in the nave where they chanted a series of solemn invocations that featured the deep baritone, quintessentially Russian voices which, until then, I’d only heard as recordings. There were many other details all-too-easy to miss: for example, the two acolytes (still obviously in their teens) dressed in cloth-of-gold dalmatics as they stood resolutely at the sanctuary doors. I also spotted two nuns - which caught me off guard since they were the first I’d encountered since arriving in a country that was full of surprises as it began to emerge from a troubled and repressive past.
It was only by chance, of course, that I’d stumbled on this unique ceremony; and I’d also arrived early enough to absorb the ambience in full. In retrospect, I’m particularly glad not to have missed the concluding moment - the climax, one might say - when the sanctuary doors slowly opened, thereby exposing to view the softly lit interior from which the Metropolitan, in blue and white vestments, advanced to the head of the steps to preach. Clearly a very old man who’d seen things that luckily, coming from abroad, we’d never had the misfortune to witness ourselves, he nevertheless spoke at length in a mellifluous, reassuring manner - something I strongly felt although I couldn’t understand a word of it. And finally, to mark the conclusion of a very long service, he headed a procession out of the building followed by the congregation whom he briefly addressed before they dispersed and made for home. As to what it was all about, however, I was still very much in the dark.
* * *
On the following morning during breakfast, my usual mealtime companions were greatly intrigued when I described my experiences of the previous day - and none more so than Ruth, David, Desmond and Joyce who were eager to visit the cathedral, and asked if I’d care to accompany them. I was more than happy to do so, of course: their curiosity was quite natural - as was my own desire to take another look at the scene of the spectacle I’d described.
And so it was that, a little over an hour later, all five of us reached the cathedral and found ourselves on exactly the same spot at the back where I’d been standing less than twenty-four hours previously. The smell of incense still lingered in the air. And for me in particular, in the absence of the former crowds, the building seemed even larger than before - and emptier, too - notwithstanding which, the lamps were still burning; and a few devout believers were loitering in dark corners, lighting candles and murmuring prayers.
For want of a better way of putting it, there was still an almost tangible sense of other-worldliness about the place; and this, for my companions, produced an awestruck silence until Ruth, with a slight tremor in her voice, expressed her support and concern for a church which, as everyone knew, had come close to extinction as a result of the communist government’s campaign against religion. And with that in mind, there was a general feeling of disappointment that now, at a time of greater freedom, they’d missed the celebration at which, by sheer chance, I’d had the good fortune to be present.
​
A Violent Interlude
After leaving the church, these reflections seemed to follow us like a cloud; and we paused just outside to gaze rather helplessly at the notice board. I think my companions were hoping there might be some sort of follow-up event - an event enabling them to gain an impression, however imperfect, of what I’d described over breakfast. All too obviously, however, none of us would have been able to understand the language even if we’d managed to master the alphabet - although the date in Roman numerals confirmed that it was 31 August 1991 and that, sadly, with the end of our holiday fast approaching, there was no time left.
Earlier on, I described Russia as a country full of surprises. And whilst we stood there chattering amongst ourselves, this casual aside was borne out when we were interrupted by the obviously English voice of a young man behind us who wondered if he could be of any assistance. It was an offer I took advantage of by mentioning the service I’d so recently attended. But before I had time to elaborate, everyone somewhat predictably chipped in and enquired whether he could shed any light on what had clearly been a major event.
He was quick to respond; and to begin with, from his detailed answer, we learned that he was attached to the monastery and was considering holy orders. From which standpoint, as things turned out, he was able to go well beyond the bare fact that the previous day, August 30, had been the feast of St Alexander Nevsky to whom the monastery and its cathedral were dedicated and where, until the Revolution, the saint’s relics had been kept. We were all well aware, of course, that the history of the Russian Revolution had been bloody; nevertheless, to put it mildly, we didn’t know what to expect and were therefore taken aback when he described the following tragedy that occurred, more or less literally, on the ground beneath our feet.
* * *
By the time disaster struck, he told us, religious institutions had been all but outlawed and, from one end of Russia to the other, church members (especially the clergy) were declared enemies of the people. As a result of this, in 1919, a squad of revolutionary zealots invaded the monastery, herding the monks outside and into their own cemetery where they were immediately shot. Not only that, he added, but priests still at the altar were also murdered and their bodies unceremoniously disposed of.
But this was not the end of the story: for in addition to sheer brutality, there was a second, more calculating motive behind these events: the object being to stamp out the popular association between religion and a national hero like Alexander Nevsky who also happened to be a canonised saint of the Orthodox Church. Consequently, in order to further this aim, the authorities had the silver sarcophagus containing the saint’s relics taken from the cathedral. After which, as a work of art, it was exhibited in The Hermitage, whereas the bodily remains were consigned to St Petersburg’s ‘Anti-Religion Museum’. And this, as our informant went on to tell us, was how things stood throughout the many intervening years until, in 1989, the Russian Government (by then more liberal) sanctioned the restoration of the relics to the Monastery - a concession, however, that so far hadn’t been extended to the sarcophagus.
We were very grateful to our informant whom we never expected to meet and whose name we never knew. And for a while after he returned to the church and disappeared inside, our conversation was perfunctory and hushed. On our way back to the hotel, however, we all agreed that the celebration I’d witnessed was something more than the feast day of St Alexander Nevsky, the national hero who accounted for so many of the country’s street names; it was also pointer to the fact that, in 1989, his relics had been returned to their former resting place. And, with luck (or so we hoped), it marked the prospect of a better future for the country at large.
Once we were back inside the hotel, although it was difficult to close our minds to what we’d seen and heard that morning, the appearance of a new set of guests reminded us of the fact that, regrettably, the next day’s excursion would be the last before our final departure for home. And in a curious way, given the many inspirational events so far met with during our travels, the return flight to Heathrow seemed much less attractive than it did when viewed from the vantage point of cold meals, cold baths and cockroaches.
​
PETRODVORETS
My recollections of St Petersburg are now nearing their end - but on a much lighter note than those of the day before. Naturally, there were very good reasons for the change of outlook: after all, our guided tour was bound for Petrodvorets (Petergof) - Peter the Great’s summer palace on the shores of the Gulf of Finland. We’d also been told that the outward journey would be by boat whilst, for added interest, the return trip to the hotel would be by coach. From the start, therefore, spirits were high.
The trip commenced with departure by hydrofoil from busy moorings on the Neva. And although the temperature had dropped to about ten degrees centigrade, there was a bright sun which ensured a generally upbeat atmosphere among the passengers as we left the river behind us and breezed along the coast towards our destination. The voyage of about twenty four miles was completed in thirty minutes or so; and this led a member of our group to point out that it was therefore on a par with the hovercraft crossing from Dover to Calais.
* * *
After disembarking, we made our way along the broad avenue leading to the palace - an avenue heavily wooded on either side and divided down the centre by a narrow canal along which the fountains behind the palace, no longer working, once disgorged their water into the sea. It was here, too, that a number of young speculators attempted unsuccessfully to sell us an assortment of military headgear and some rather clumsy watches of similar provenance. It was a familiar but awkward encounter; and as we ambled past them with our minds focussed elsewhere, their disappointment (accompanied by resignation) was plain to see.
Before going any further, it’s important to appreciate the effects of World War II on Petrodvorets - particularly during the Siege of Leningrad when the German military used it as a barracks and treated it with complete disregard. Moreover, as an act of revenge when things turned against them and their troops were forced out, they blew it up as a final gesture of defiance. It was therefore something of a miracle that, under an anti-monarchist Soviet government, a royal palace had been so spectacularly restored to its former magnificence. And when shown some photographs taken just after its destruction, I found it even harder to imagine how this had been managed with such obvious thoroughness.
Following our arrival, and after some reasonably appetising on-site snacks, our introduction to the palace’s many ornate salons was led by our permanent guide who ably maintained our interest despite the surfeit of material worthy of our attention. For example, the sumptuous silk wall hangings, the mauve chandeliers, the Chinese study, and Peter the Great’s throne room - although I was never quite clear whether the throne itself was a survival or a replica. Nevertheless, although some of the restoration work was clearly carried out in haste, it still added up to an interesting picture of the past and a worthy tribute to the nation’s determination to fight back. At the same time, speaking personally, I somehow felt a competing desire to examine the external architecture accompanied, perhaps, by a stroll in the extensive gardens.
* * *
Before we left, there was just one more memorable incident - small, unforeseen yet significant; and it occurred during the final half hour which had been set aside exclusively for those wishing to take holiday snaps. Instead of taking holiday snaps, however, I took the opportunity to explore. And consequently, somewhat further afield and close to the coach park, I encountered a modest cluster of stalls and boutiques selling good quality crafts and souvenirs. And it was there, out of the many items I brought back with me from Russia, that I pounced on the most enviable of them all. It consisted of a particularly finely decorated lacquer box featuring ‘St George and the Dragon’. Time was short, of course; so I acted on the spur of the moment. I could see no alternative... I just had to have it.
What struck me almost as much as the box itself, however, was the fact that the youthful vendor was so delighted with the seventy dollars I gave for it that, just moments after I’d left, he pursued me with a plastic bag to put it in. And it didn’t take much intelligence to work out what led him to do so. When all’s said and done, given the economic conditions of the day, seventy dollars was a princely sum. And consequently, his obvious pleasure reconciled me to having knocked him down from the original asking price of a hundred dollars. What’s more, the fact that on a nondescript road in his own country he’d asked for dollars rather than roubles spoke volumes.
Back to the Hotel
As arranged, we returned to St Petersburg by coach, driving disappointingly quickly through pleasant woodland areas punctuated at intervals by green fields reminiscent of the UK and yet oddly at distinctive - although it’s hard to define exactly what I mean by saying so. Perhaps the closest I can get to an explanation is to liken it to the same scene painted by two different artists.
Looking back once again, and speaking as a lifelong country lover, I’m not at all sure I wouldn’t have preferred replacing the trip to Petrodvorets with an opportunity to explore this rarely visited Russian landscape of woods, intermittent birch copses and wayside flora. Unfortunately, however, given the tight schedule, there was no chance to investigate even one of the villages I glimpsed all-too-briefly as the coach picked up speed. And most regrettable of all, at least for me, there was no possibility of getting any closer to a marvellous redbrick church with brightly painted domes (much more intensely rustic in style than most we’d so far seen) and several large country mansions that still lay in ruins in the wake of the Nazi onslaught.
This, to my mind, was a truly congenial landscape in which one would have liked to linger. Unremarkable yet homely, I still remember a middle-aged woman walking her dog along a railway track; and as we whisked past, I found myself wondering where she lived and, if she had a garden, what sort of flowers or vegetables she grew in it. Altogether, everything felt more stable and much more authentically indigenous in the open country than it did among the crowded streets and city tower blocks that reappeared soon enough and continued to pursue us... on and monotonously on... until we finally reached the hotel on the eve of the final twenty-four hours of a memorable holiday.
THE LAST LEG
After returning from Petrodvorets, gulping down some light refreshments and fruitlessly combing Nevsky Prospekt one last time for worthwhile souvenirs, our fortnight’s whistle-stop tour concluded that evening at a nearby theatre with a performance by the Georgian State Dancers and Singers - a production that was unique in form, plaintive in sound and highly polished. Nevertheless, before going inside, the final bargains of the holiday were virtually thrown at us on the steps by a group of young hotheads who were getting under everyone’s feet and were most easily got rid of by buying a tin or two of their cut-price caviar for what was an undoubtedly competitive sum. And that was that. We all thoroughly enjoyed ourselves... I added a 33rpm record of Georgian music to my collection of holiday mementoes... after which we were driven back to the hotel for some last-minute packing and a night’s sleep before the following day’s journey home to London Heathrow.
The next morning’s departure from the city airport was not as smooth as the coach drive that took us there; in fact, it was traumatic. Most of the terminal buildings were closed for reconstruction which created a human log-jam of worrying proportions. Worse still, anyone with leftover roubles had to exchange them for foreign currency at a desk a long way off and operated by a single clerk. This meant I had to abandon most of my fellow-travellers and my place in the queue - a stressful obligation that was by no means mitigated by a brass band in the forecourt playing ‘God Save The Queen’.
Having complied with all the necessary regulations, a final check in the duty-free shop confirmed that the price of the carefully packed goods in my luggage couldn’t be improved on - which left just one remaining and, to begin with, rather alarming obstacle between myself and a comfortable seat on the aircraft. What it boiled down to was the fact that I had to pass no fewer than four times through the metal detector until it was discovered that the persistently repeated bleeps were caused by the last of four possible objects: namely, by my pocket calculator. The police officer in charge, to give him due credit, clearly thought it was all rather amusing; and to conceal my embarrassment, I pretended that I thought so, too!
END OF THE ROAD
The flight home was uneventful and, since the spectacle of Planet Earth as seen from above has always fuelled my interest in space travel, I secured a window seat. High altitudes, once attained, restored sunshine to a hitherto dull morning; and setting aside imaginary trips to Mars, I soon discovered I was surrounded by a group of eager schoolchildren en route to the West for the first time. Other than that, I remember thinking the Aeroflot lunch was poised somewhere between a near miss and a last-minute stop gap - although now, with the passage of time, I can’t honestly remember what it consisted of.
The final point of interest, however, lay in the conversation I overheard between one of my fellow tourists and a young Russian travelling on a two-year attachment to Sussex University. I wondered what he would make of the rolling South Downs or the pleasant villages inhabited by families in comfortable circumstances. And what about the carefree summer revelries in Brighton, I wondered? On the other hand, based on experience, I hoped someone would prepare him for the fact that the level of freedom he was about to encounter was sometimes accompanied by coldness or indifference towards others. For the time being, however, when asked if he was thinking of going back to Russia after finishing his studies, his reply was a categorical (and confidential) ‘not if I can help it!’
* * *
At Heathrow, it was hot and sunny - which did very little to relieve the sense of flatness that so often accompanies the end of an overseas break. To tell the truth, I felt the onset of weariness from the moment I realised we were losing height. And once we’d landed, whilst waiting for the conveyor belt to deliver the luggage, there was no improvement. The final point of negativity struck home even more forcibly when I realised that all the people I’d known throughout the trip had somehow collected their bags and faded away like ghosts without so much as a handshake. I still remember them, of course; but I never saw any of them again - with the one exception of David whom I stumbled on a year later in St Johns Wood where he dismissed the Russian experience as ‘quite interesting but not much of a holiday’.
Meanwhile, the thought of preparing a meal when I got home presented a very unwelcome challenge - a challenge I outmanoeuvred, before I reached the underground, by securing a bottle of white wine, a tub of prepared Greek salad, some butter and a packet of crispbreads. Furthermore, I assured myself, my suitcase contained several tins of Russian caviar, one of which could certainly be included in the menu without feeling unreasonably gluttonous. At the same time, I also thought how nice it would be to accompany the enjoyment of good food by trying out my brand new record of Georgian music. And readers will no doubt be interested to hear that, by the time the evening came to an end, ‘nice’ wasn’t the only way of describing it - although whether this was due to the caviar, the music or a half-empty bottle of wine is a question without a simple answer.
​​
Russian place names. Ulitsa: street or road. Prospekt: a wide, multi-lane, city avenue. Ploshchad: square. Most: bridge.
Lavra: monastery. Baboushka: older woman or granny. Dvorets: palace - Petrodvorets, Komsomol: before the collapse of the USSR, a nationwide Communist youth organisation.
Metropolitan: a Russian bishop ranking above an archbishop and below a patriarch.
Iconostasis: a screen, bearing icons, that separates the sanctuary of a Russian church from the nave.
Dalmatic: In the Latin church, a long, wide-sleeved, open-sided vestment, similar to that described in the text, whose Russian name I’m unaware of.
Feliks Dzierzynski: Russian Bolshevik leader and subsequent head of the All-Russian Extraordinary Commission (Cheka), tasking him with the suppression of counter-revolutionary activities in Soviet Russia.
Perestroika & Glasnost: Perestroika was a policy of economical and political reform initiated in 1979 by Mikhail Gorbachev. In 1985, he also introduced an increasingly open, consultative form of government known as Glasnost.
Sir Frank Brangwyn: 1867 - 1956, Welsh painter born in Belgium; best known for his large murals.
Here are a few original photos taken by Ross during his 1991trip to Russia: